Bold Pilot Poster Child


"There are old pilots, and there are bold pilots; but there are no old bold pilots."  So goes the aviation adage.

Never mind old-fashioned wisdom now, thanks to Cirrus flight into known icing (FIKI) capability.  I introduce, bold pilot: Cirrus Design's co-founder, Dale Klapmeier, featured on Cirrus Design's website.


"The forecast wasn’t good, so we were racing the storm to get out there." -Dale Klapmeier

Klapmeier braggadociously explains his ability to fly in ice, at night, in the mountains, in a Cirrus-spun solution to "get-there-itis".1 For the purpose of this critique, Klapmeier's smug video-taped story also transcribed below:

 

Dale Klapmeier, Co-Founder and Vice-Chairman on “Being FIKI Capable”
Transcribed February 8, 2010, from the Cirrus Design website:
http://www.cirrusaircraft.com/perspective/fiki.aspx

In early January of this year, I was able to take the prototype FIKI airplane out to Jackson Hole, Wyoming.  I had my youngest son with me.  We were going out for a long weekend skiing.  The forecast wasn’t good, so we were racing the storm to get out there.  About over the Black Hills we started to get into the ice.  Because of the winds, we were down low.  Each time that we encountered the ice we would keep climbing.  We ended up at 18,000 feet over the Rockies getting ready to shoot our approach into Jackson Hole.

[SLIDE: "Cirrus Known Ice Protection Delivers Peace of Mind"]

We were watching the weather all the way out.  We’ve gotta shoot this approach.  We know we’ve got 12,000 feet of ice to get down through.  When we turned the system on, you immediately see the entire wing covered in fluid.  So with this system, I no longer have to worry about de-icing.  I was worried now about the approach.  It’s night.  The tower closes at nine o’clock.  We basically got [sic] one opportunity to shoot this approach, and we’ve got to get in.  We were not going to turn it off until we were on the ground.  We had the fluid, we had the range, shoot the approach.

[SLIDE: "Cirrus Known Ice Protection Delivers Confidence"]

This system works great.  It allowed me to take my son through the weather, out to the mountains, ski for the weekend, and then still get back.  This system gives you the confidence to know that you get to where you need to be and get home again.  That’s the utility that this airplane gives you.

[SLIDE: "FLYING 2.0 CHANGING THE WAY YOU TRAVEL"]
 
According to manufacturer Cirrus, the FIKI system "delivers peace of mind".  It "delivers confidence", the kind of confidence that Dale Klapmeier himself exhibited on this harrowing flight.

To whom does the Cirrus FIKI airplane deliver confidence?  YOU!  Any pilot for that matter as there's no mention of competence, a requisite of confidence.  Never mind common sense: not to put yourself voluntarily into a "got to get in" situation.  Forgo the advice to always leave yourself an out.

Has there ever been a car commercial that doesn't disclaim, "Professional Driver on Closed Course."  There's no such caution from Cirrus, quite the opposite.  To quote Cirrus, "With Known Ice Protection on the new SR22 and Turbo, pilots can now launch or continue flight with the peace of mind that they’re both legal and safe when icing is forecast or present."

Undoubtedly, the Cirrus known ice system does indeed improve its safety.  The TKS system is effective to navigate periodic icing conditions.  However, by no means would a prudent pilot bet his or her life, or commit lives of innocent passengers to an assumption that FIKI will not fail during extended flight into ice as the laminar flow wing depends upon it.

Youngest son on board, dudely Klapmeier takes his chance, "We know we’ve got 12,000 feet of ice to get down through."  "We basically got [sic] one opportunity to shoot this approach, and we’ve got to get in." After all, skiing is important enough to race in front of a storm, IFR at night, single-pilot over inhospitable terrain in known icing conditions with his passenger.

1 The pressure of "get-there-itis," can sometimes induce a decision to launch or continue in less than ideal weather conditions.  FAA Flight Instructor Training Module Volume 2- System Safety Course Developers Guide V 1.1
 
Trackbacks
  • 2/11/2010 2:34 PM Aviation Law Monitor wrote:
    Cirrus aircraft are now available with "flight into known icing" (FIKI) capability. That's a great feature. I've written before, however, that Cirrus is asking for trouble with its marketing. Cirrus sells the feature as one that both enhances safety and...
Comments

  • 2/10/2010 4:45 PM Anonymous wrote:
    WOW! Without a doubt the most irresponsible piece of "advertising" in existence!!
    Reply to this
  • 2/11/2010 8:16 AM Matt wrote:
    Seems like just the wrong message. If I can do it...YOU can do it.

    What was it they taught us CFI's about hazardous attitudes...MACHO anyone?
    Reply to this
  • 2/11/2010 1:51 PM Mike Danko wrote:
    My gripe is that Cirrus markets FIKI as both a safety feature and one that increases the aircraft's utility. [www.aviationlawmonitor.com/2009/05/articles/general-aviation/recent-crashes-stoke-debate-on-cirrus-safety/] A feature can't do both. Using a feature to increase the aircraft's utility (by, for example, flying in conditions that would otherwise keep you on the ground)necessarily undermines the feature's safety benefits. You can't have it both ways and Cirrus' marketing is asking for trouble.
    Reply to this
  • 2/13/2010 8:59 PM Ric Fulop wrote:
    I own a Cirrus Turbo with FIKI and have to say its a true breakthrough! The Cirrus training for FIKI is excellent! In the northeast I'd much rather bein a Cirrus with FIKI and CAPS parachute than naked Cessna 400. Steve needs to take a ride on my plane!
    Reply to this
  • 6/26/2010 1:34 AM Onketing wrote:
    Nice and interesting topic related to the pilot,well nice and bold article keep it up..
    Reply to this
  • 12/23/2010 3:26 PM NT Ice wrote:
    Re: get-there-itis . . .
    I remember the time my dad flew with his chief engineer on a business trip to southern Ohio from Fort Wayne, Indiana. When it came time for the return trip, rain clouds were gathering. Everybody wanted to get home to sleep in their own beds after an overnight and an all-day business meeting.
    My dad asked his chief engineer (the pilot of the single-engine plane they had flown there in), "If we were home, would you take off in this weather?"
    The answer was no. So they rented a car and got home by 2:00 AM.
    My dad lived another thirty-five years and died in his bed.
    He could have died that night of get-there-itis, and I'm glad he didn't.
    Reply to this
Leave a comment

Submitted comments are subject to moderation before being displayed.

 Name

 Email (will not be published)

 Website

Your comment is 0 characters limited to 3000 characters.